Workers’ compensation premiums are usually set at the start of the year using estimated payroll. After the policy ends, the carrier typically checks those estimates against actual figures through a premium audit. For many employers, understanding the process can prevent surprise invoices and disagreements.
What the Audit Is For
The audit compares the payroll and job classifications you estimated with what actually occurred during the policy period. If your actual payroll was higher than estimated, you may owe additional premium. If it was lower, you may receive a return. Audits are a normal part of how this coverage works and do not necessarily signal a problem.
Types of Audits
Audits may be done in person, by phone, by mail, or through a virtual review of documents. The carrier chooses the method, often based on premium size and complexity. Some employers receive a form to complete and return along with supporting records.
Records Auditors Commonly Request
Auditors often ask for payroll registers, quarterly payroll tax filings, general ledger information, and records of payments to subcontractors or other non-employees. They may also ask for certificates of insurance from independent contractors. Being able to show who worked for you, what they were paid, and what they did is central to the process.
Classification Questions
Each employee is generally assigned a class code that reflects their duties, and rates vary by code. An auditor may ask about job descriptions to confirm whether employees are properly classified. Workers who split their time between different types of work may be treated differently depending on state rules and carrier practice. Clear records of job duties and time allocation can help.
What Counts as Payroll
Definitions of payroll differ by state, but commonly include wages, bonuses, commissions, and certain other compensation. Some items may be excluded or limited, such as certain overtime premiums, certain employee benefits, or the pay of some executive officers above or below specified thresholds. Ask your agent how your state treats these items so you can organize your records accordingly.
Independent Contractors and Uninsured Subs
If you pay independent contractors who do not carry their own workers’ compensation coverage, the auditor may count those payments as payroll for premium purposes. Collecting certificates of insurance before work begins, and renewing them annually, can help show that those costs should be treated differently.
Preparing Throughout the Year
Rather than gathering records at the last minute, review your estimates at mid-year, update your agent when you hire or reduce staff, and keep payroll and subcontractor records organized. If you think a classification is incorrect, raise it before the audit ends.
If You Disagree
If an audit result appears wrong, you can typically ask for a detailed worksheet, submit corrected information, and request a review. Keep copies of all communication, and respond within the deadlines the carrier gives.
Audit practices differ by carrier and state. An independent agent can help you estimate payroll accurately, set up simple record-keeping, and compare how different carriers handle audits.